Back to Directory of Site URLs on OJW #149
Posted to ESCO August 10:
Post to ESCO 080308:
Item 151. July 31, 2008: Begin OJW CB: This case is interesting b/c for the first time I used the "through-the-bracket" (t-t-b) method of wiring the jaws apart permitting CB a greater range of lower jaw movement in all direction as you will see from the photos. CB came with her husband who I taught how to wire using this t-t-b method. Moreover, we discussed the possibility of using "monofilament" fishing line as an alternative to wire. Finally, CB is going to post her thoughts to her own blog.
http://www.drted.com/OJW CB 073108.htm
http://upyourfats.blogspot.com
Cordially,
Response from Dr. Rothstein:
Subject: Ten reasons to provide the Orthodontic Jaw Wiring Service as per Dr. Moscowitz
TEN REASONS TO PROVIDE OJW TO THE OVERWEIGHT/OBESE IN YOUR PRACTICE AND YOUR COMMUNITY
1. You believe that providing this service as part of a “healthcare team” would enhance your image in the community in which you practice.
2. You are an orthodontist/dentist who believes the "risk / benefit" ratio of OJW would be inside your "comfort zone.“
3. You strongly believe dentists are guardians of the mouth and the TM joint and are well positioned in helping the overweight.
4. You are not overweight or obese, nor are your staff members, and therefore offering OJW in your office would not bring undesirable and embarrassing attention to you or your staff members.
5. You are a dentist/orthodontist who is quite capable of bonding a bracket to a tooth.
6. You believe that OJW is effective and safe.
7. You believe dentists are professional health providers who should be helping the overweight.
8. You feel strongly that OJW is relatively safe to provide and puts you at no greater risk liability-wise than you are already.
9. You know your dental license is not in jeopardy. Why should it be?
10. You believe that the new DDS System clears the way for dentists to provide services to the overweight, and providing OJW still further implements your armamentarium.
JUNE 6, 2008
Date: Sun, 13 Jul 2008 02:09:38 EDT From: Typodont@AOL.COM
Subject: Re: Role of our Editors
-The role of the editor(s)
Rarely would I comment on this subject, but I think that it speaks to the
fundamental problems of any internet based orthodontic forum. No doubt,
this forum gives all of us an opportunity to raise questions, share
experiences, propose new directions, and discuss orthodontic related
information that would most likely not be covered in our professional
publications (peer reviewed or otherwise). To a large extent, each and
every one of us in orthodontics have been empowered with respect to having
the opportunity to be listened to any particular subject in orthodontics.
It is a unique media, however, not without its thorns. Unsupervised
information internet sites have the potential to degenerate into
meaningless, sophomoric, and silly type of rooms And just whenever this one
seems to be heading that way, I am pleasantly surprised to see the direction
or focus of information favorably change. I
cannot believe that our ESCO editors are not responsible to some degree to
shifting the orthodontic conversations into better places when needed. This
brings us to the rather serious and awesome responsibility of any editor.
In all fairness to our editors, they are, to a fault, rather accepting as to
the subjects as well as to the scope of dialogue on any particular subject.
Although it may seem regrettable to some of our ESCO participants, editors
must exercise some degree of editorial license with respect to what they
accept and how much latitude they will give to individual subjects and
contributors. If not, this forum will deteriorate to the lowest common
denominator; and it will do so rather quickly. Although none of us will be
completely satisfied with the content of each and every ESCO listing, there
seems to be enough good orthodontic conversation to keep us all coming
back. On balance, therefore, I think that our editors are doing rather
nicely while we all learn to use the relatively new communication vehicle of
the internet. Any editor must sift through at times voluminous material and
separate the gold from the dross none of us are perfect and we error.
However, in addition to each of us who contribute to ESCO regularly, or from
time to time, it is ultimately, the editors, who have the responsibility of
establishing and maintaining certain standards of content and discussion.
And naturally, all this is accompanied by editorial criticism from all of
us. Editors learn to have somewhat thicker skin than most because some of
our contributors may not be completely satisfied with either the subject or
content of our postings at any given time. And of course, forums such as
ESCO, generically, will also invite the great in our specialty who
sometimes present discussions that are somewhere in between Voodoo worship
and the Psychic Hotline. In most instances, such discussions are easily
identified and managed even with the most persistent and energetic
proponents of such idiocy. What remains to this ESCO subscriber, is
essentially some valuable information that might help us treat our patients
a little better tomorrow or at the very least stimulate us to want to learn
more about any particular subject. While it may be disheartening for some of
us to know that some judicious censorship must be implemented, such
editorial overseeing does not preclude openness, fairness, and forward
thinking, In the end, many of us are permit ted to offer comments but not
necessarily empowered to use this forum as a soap box for self promotion.
The latter would clearly represent professional communication abuse of this
forum. Elliott M Moskowitz, D.D.S.,M.Sd, New York City
RESPONSE TO ESCO JULY 11, 2008
TEN REASONS TO PROVIDE OJW TO THE OVERWEIGHT/OBESE IN YOUR PRACTICE AND YOUR COMMUNITY
1. You believe that providing this service as part of a “healthcare team” would enhance your image in the community in which you practice.
2. You are an orthodontist/dentist who believes the "risk / benefit" ratio of OJW would be inside your "comfort zone.“
3. You strongly believe dentists are guardians of the mouth and the TM joint and are well positioned in helping the overweight.
4. You are not overweight or obese, nor are your staff members, and therefore offering OJW in your office would not bring undesirable and embarrassing attention to you or your staff members.
5. You are a dentist/orthodontist who is quite capable of bonding a bracket to a tooth.
6. You believe that OJW is effective and safe.
7. You believe dentists are professional health providers who should be helping the overweight.
8. You feel strongly that OJW is relatively safe to provide and puts you at no greater risk liability-wise than you are already.
9. You know your dental license is not in jeopardy. Why should it be?
10. You believe that the new DDS System clears the way for dentists to provide services to the overweight, and providing OJW still further implements your armamentarium.
JUNE 6, 2008
RECEIVED FROM ESCO JULY 9, 2008
Date: Wed, 9 Jul 2008 13:01:23 EDT
From: Diane Johnson <DHMJDDS@AOL.COM>
Subject: Re: ESCO Digest - 2 Jul 2008 to 7 Jul 2008 (#2008-67)
-------------------------------1215622883
Content-Type: text/plain; charset="US-ASCII"
Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit
Teddy--
If you think so highly of our swinish opinions, you certainly have the
option to discontinue posting. You may then post to the
already-converted-to-your-way-of-seeing-things-forum. There is a another
phrase for that: preaching
to the choir.
Sorry, bud, it is our DUTY to be skeptical of these things. When someone,
out of the clear blue sky, comes up with a wild new technique, e.g. Fat
people
need their teeth wired shut so they won't eat; we can charge them money for
this; ergo, we should do this, and posts it to this forum, that someone is
delusional if he or she thinks that everyone is going to embrace him and
sing
hallelujah. This is particularly true if that someone has a web site that
anoints that someone with specialties that are made up and that is full of
hyperbole about qualifications and abilities.
This forum is for discussion, and even dissection, of orthodontics and
related subjects. Your technique is a related subject, but if you are
selling
something, I still think that is inappropriate to post. I am not one who
would
advocate blocking your posts, or anyone's posts, as long as they are
decent,
basically on topic, and not terribly ad hominem. I don't think it is
reasonable to expect us to be completely non-ad-hominem. The weight given
to each
person's argument for or against something is always going to be influenced
by
our judgements of their opinions on other subjects, their ability to make
an
intelligent, cogent argument, and our estimate of their expert status in
regards to the subject they are discussing.
I do absolutely agree with you that everyone must sign their posts with
their real names, not just their email or screen names. No fair
criticizing
someone else as "anonymous." But also, enough pouting from anyone who gets
even
the mildest criticism. Dr. Matasa, Barry's comment really wasn't mean at
all. "C," to my knowledge, no one has ever criticized you on this forum.
Guys
who send me private emails to thank me for saying what they were thinking:
thank you all very much, but also please stand up for yourselves.
OK, now I'm off topic. I promise something new and different next time.
This is why I love orthodontics: Something new and different walks into my
office every single day.
Diane Johnson
Topics of the day:
1. Writing to ESCO: FLAK * jackets on!
2. "Removing braces": A YouTube film by Dr. Ted Rothstein
Date: Fri, 4 Jul 2008 05:59:32 EDT
From: Drted35@AOL.COM
Subject: Writing to ESCO: FLAK * jackets on!
*FLAK
Etymology: German, from Fliegerabwehrkanonen, from Flieger flyer + Abwehr
defense + Kanonen cannons
Date: 1938
Ted Rothstein, DDS, PhD Life active member AAO
Specialist in Cosmetic Orthodontics _Specialist in OJW_
(http://www.drted.com/index.html.bak2/jaw_wiring.htm)
Founder DPOJW _www.drted.com/DPOJW.html_ (http://www.drted.com/DPOJW.html)
35 Remsen St. Brooklyn, NY 11201
(718) 852-1551 _www.drted.com_ (http://www.drted.com/) _drted35@aol.com_
Dear C:
I completely understand how you feel.
You are not the first person to be beaten off and driven away by some of ou
r
ESCO colleagues who spout endless drivel while attacking mercilessly.(See
below.)
Sometimes I find it hard to believe how petty, mean-spirited some of these
commentators can be I could go on...
Here is an apt expression for the some of the ESCO commentariat when you
prepare to write in your pearl: Do not cast your pearls before swine
Do not waste good things on people who will not appreciate them. This
_proverb_ (http://www.bartleby.com/59/7/proverb.html) is adapted from a sa
ying of
_Jesus_ (http://www.bartleby.com/59/1/jesus.html) from the _Gospels_
(http://www.bartleby.com/59/1/gospels.html) , E2809C_Cast not pearls bef
ore swine_
(http://www.bartleby.com/59/1/pearlsbefore.html) .E2809D Jesus appears to
be warning his
_disciples_ (http://www.bartleby.com/59/1/disciples.html) to preach only
before receptive audiences.
The brouhaha this will raise will no doubt wake the dead. Let the
commentariat begin their bloviations.
I love the sport of the witty retort. It's just a game you play with verba
l
bullies. It's good to exercise your sense of humor.
As for the DVD. the film was made and aired on miniDV tape and is being
converted to DVD format. I'll put your name on my list of people who have
requested the DVD.
The ten-minute version will air on YouTube in a few week.
Can I post this entire note to the ESCO forum? I promise I will delete all
traces of your identity.
I just had another orthodontist and university professor to timid to take a
stand who asked if I would write a letter to ESCO to chastise some of the
more vocal bloviators who made a mockery of him when he most recently prese
nted
a beautiful piece of research on bracket adhesion v pad configuration. It
was like someone booted him in the gut. He was demoralized.
In the meantime just go to drted.com and the world of orthodontic jaw wirin
g
(OJW) will appear.
See the rubrics on the home page "orthodontic jaw wiring" and the
'OJW-dpojw course".
Cordially, Ted
Have a safe and happy July 4th
In a message dated 7/3/2008 8:05:59 P.M. Eastern Daylight Time,
_xxxxxxxxxx@xxxx.xxxxxxx.xxx_ (mailto:xxxxxxxxxx@xxxx.xxxxxxx.xxx) writes:
Dear Dr. Rothstein,
I am an xxx orthodontist - actually a full-time xxxx xx xxxx xxx for 5 year
s
now - and would greatly appreciate viewing your dvd regarding OJW. I am
starved for any ortho related information and am completely unfamiliar with
the
technique. Also being a person who avoids conflict at nearly all costs, I
must say that I admire you "staying the course" with various hostile ESCO
contributors. This is the main reason that I am an avid ready and infreque
nt
contributor.
Date: Thu, 3 Jul 2008 19:45:09 EDT
From: Drted35@AOL.COM
Subject: "Removing braces": A YouTube film by Dr. Ted Rothstein
Ted Rothstein, DDS, PhD Life active member AAO
Specialist in Cosmetic Orthodontics _Specialist in OJW_
(http://www.drted.com/index.html.bak2/jaw_wiring.htm)
Founder DPOJW _www.drted.com/DPOJW.html_ (http://www.drted.com/DPOJW.html)
35 Remsen St. Brooklyn, NY 11201
(718) 852-1551 _www.drted.com_ (http://www.drted.com/) _drted35@aol.com_
(mailto:drted35@aol.com)
Dear Esteemed Colleagues:
See it at: _http://youtube.com/user/drteddrted_
(http://youtube.com/user/drteddrted)
July 3, 2008: Today I received a new comment on my YouTube video from a
patient in another doctor's practice who wrote:
"thank you for adding this video i can't imagine how easy it is ti have
braces on my teeth i was so scared to death and i hope it would be the same
as
for removing them
I responded:
"Thank you for taking the time to write this note. The film was intended to
diminish the anxiety of the unknown. Tell, show and do is a common technique
to allay patient fear. There was no "show" for removing braces. Now there
is
one. Judging from the kind remarks of patients like yourself it appears
that
this film has made a difference, and these kind remarks are my reward.
Dr. Ted Rothstein: drted.com 070308"
The next time your patient inquires about removing braces do them a favor
and send them to: _http://youtube.com/user/drteddrted_
(http://youtube.com/user/drteddrted)
Enjoy. Ted
The "C." a another person name Carl who wrote me yesterday. It reminded me of you so I wrote this letter. Ted
DR. ROTHSTEIN RESPONDS TO THE MEAN-SPIRITED AND PETTY ON BEHALF OF TWO DOCTORS WHO WERE TORMENTED BY THE "COMMENTARIAT" WHO FIND JOY IN BULLYING, TORMENTING OR DENIGRATING OTHER CONTRIBUTORS TO ESCO
"SUBJECT: Writing to ESCO: FLAK * jackets on!
| Do not cast your pearls before swine |
|
Do not waste good things on people who will not
appreciate them. This
proverb is adapted from a saying of
Jesus from the
Gospels, “Cast
not pearls before swine.” Jesus appears to be
warning his
disciples to preach only before receptive audiences.
The brouhaha this will raise will
no doubt wake the dead. Let the commentariat begin their
bloviations.
I love the sport of the witty retort.
It's just a game you play with verbal bullies. It's good
to exercise your sense of humor.
As for the DVD. the film was made and
aired on miniDV tape and is being converted to DVD
format. I'll put your name on my list of people who have
requested the DVD.
The ten-minute version will air on
YouTube in a few week.
Can I post this entire note to the ESCO
forum? I promise I will delete all traces of your
identity.
I just had another orthodontist and
university professor to timid to take a stand who asked
if I would write a letter to ESCO to chastise some of
the more vocal bloviators who made a mockery of him
when he most recently presented a beautiful piece of
research on bracket adhesion v pad configuration. It was
like someone booted him in the gut. He was demoralized.
In the meantime just go to drted.com and
the world of orthodontic jaw wiring (OJW) will appear.
See the rubrics on the home page
"orthodontic jaw wiring" and the 'OJW-dpojw course".
Cordially, Ted
Have a safe and happy July 4th
|
Dear Dr. Rothstein,I am an xxx orthodontist - actually a full-time xxxx xx xxxx xxx for 5 years now - and would greatly appreciate viewing your dvd regarding OJW. I am starved for any ortho related information and am completely unfamiliar with the technique. Also being a person who avoids conflict at nearly all costs, I must say that I admire you "staying the course" with various hostile ESCO contributors. This is the main reason that I am an avid ready and infrequent contributor.
Dear Dr. Rothstein
You are an active contributor to ESCO. Last May, some of its subscribers invited the readers to share their experience regarding bracket properties.
It has been more than 20 years since I published my first article in this field ("Not all appliances are created equal," Am. J. Orthod. Dentofac Orthop 1988; 94: 168-169) and I hope to continue to do so in “The Orthodontic Materials Insider” and elsewhere. In its last issue, I wrote two articles regarding bracket bond strength.In the first, I presented an engineer’s point of view. In the second, I explored the results of in-vitro application on 32 brackets exhibiting differences in base structure. To reduce variables and approach a full cross-linking of the adhesive (i.e., strength), I used heat. Indeed, in-office procedures have to be fast and the techniques and the materials available are many. Post cure is common in industry (search “post cure glossary”) and even in dental research (http://www.springerlink.com/content/r4805p772652880j).
The bonding of metals, plastics or ceramics has been well explored in industry, and is not confined to the particular case of orthodontics. To my surprise, my study (www.OrthodonticMaterials.com, June 2008) has been greeted at ESCO with the comment: “If I read this right, the best way to improve bond strength is to cook or microwave our patients. Thanks…a lot…”
I wonder if this type of problematic humor would encourage others to respond to the Club’s invitations...Claude G. Matasa, DCE, DSc., DHC
Professor Adjunct,
U. Illinois, Chicago
www.Matasa.netSUBJECT: allan sheridan <captainal_92865@YAHOO.COM>
DR. ROTHSTEIN RESPONDS TO DR. ALLAN SHERIDAN'S REMARK BELOW:
Date: Wed, 2 Jul 2008 07:44:38 -0700
From: allan sheridan <captainal_92865@YAHOO.COM>
Subject: Rothstein--can we list him as "Spam" ???
We have so much that is important to share--can the site de-list Dr. Rothstein as Brooklyns best jaw wirer and have him sent to spam???
Allan Sheridan DDS, MS, JD
RESPONSE
It seems that someone died and left Dr. Sheridan to be king of the dung heap: For more information see:Scarab Beetles
ORDER: COLEOPTERA
FAMILY:SCARABAEIDAE
DR. ROTHSTEIN AGAIN CONTRIBUTES TO ESCO TRYING TO GET SOME PRODUCTIVE FEEDBACK
SUBJECT: From Ted Rothstein. Stay focused on the message. " The gates to the future...Ted Rothstein, DDS, PhD Life active member AAO
Specialist in Cosmetic Orthodontics Specialist in OJW
Founder DPOJW www.drted.com/DPOJW.html
35 Remsen St. Brooklyn, NY 11201
(718) 852-1551 www.drted.com drted35@aol.comThe gates to the future are guarded by a thousand sentries of the past.Dear Voices of ESCO,First of all, and above all, I wish you all a happy and safe 4th of July. :-) including Templedentist@gmail.comwhoever he may be.Please try to stay focused on the message and the potential benefits to yourself, your community and the obese.Here is the message:I am confident that in time OJW will become a service that members of the dental community provide with pleasure in their own communities. I have no doubt that there will never cease to be members of the dental and medical community who look upon OJW with a jaundiced eye. I say offer the service, choose your patients carefully, do the OJW methodically and be responsive to patients needs.Most of the compulsively overweight will applaud your efforts to help them and they will not hold it against you if they regain the weight. They do expect you would-be providers to see to it that no harm is coming to them because of the OJW.
You need to make sure their teeth, gums and jaw joints are not being harmed and to remove the appliance when they request it, and even before that if you think no benefit is being derived.
The Informed Consent for OJW
http://www.drted.com/index.html.bak2/Jaw wiring Informed Cconsent.htmOrthodontic Jaw Wiring (OJW): The Dental Professional’s Role in Weight Control for Compulsive Overeating Leading to Obesity: an article submitted to the American Journal of Orthodontics and Dentofacial Orthopedics on October 28, 2007.
http://www.drted.com/OJW AJO-DO Manuscript 102607.htmCordially, TedPs, Beyond the ESCO forum I cordially invite and welcome your comments and questions posed in a private email dialogue/correspondence. Any emails sent directly to me will remain strictly private. drted35@aol.comPps: The 56-minute DVD on the development and application of OJW is available gratis on request.PPps: Those of you are interested are welcome to be present gratis to observe how OJW is provided in my office.DR. ROTHSTEIN ANNOUNCES TO ESCO THE POSTING OF HIS FILM ON YOUTUBE: ON "REMOVING BRACES"
SUBJECT: "Removing braces": A YouTube film by Dr. Ted Rothstein
Ted Rothstein, DDS, PhD Life active member AAO
Specialist in Cosmetic Orthodontics Specialist in OJW
Founder DPOJW www.drted.com/DPOJW.html
35 Remsen St. Brooklyn, NY 11201
(718) 852-1551 www.drted.com drted35@aol.comDear Esteemed Colleagues:See it at: http://youtube.com/user/drteddrtedJuly 3, 2008: Today I received a new comment on my YouTube video from a patient in another doctor's practice who wrote:"thank you for adding this video i can't imagine how easy it is ti have braces on my teeth i was so scared to death and i hope it would be the same as for removing themI responded:"Thank you for taking the time to write this note. The film was intended to diminish the anxiety of the unknown. Tell, show and do is a common technique to allay patient fear. There was no "show" for removing braces. Now there is one. Judging from the kind remarks of patients like yourself it appears that this film has made a difference, and these kind remarks are my reward.Dr. Ted Rothstein: drted.com 070308"The next time your patient inquires about removing braces do them a favor and send them to: http://youtube.com/user/drteddrtedEnjoy. Ted
There are 5 messages totalling 407 lines in this issue.
Topics of the day:
1. Postings to the esco (2)
2. Andrews Articulator
3. The Matasa Study
4. ESCO Digest - 19 Jun 2008 to 23 Jun 2008 - Special issue (#2008-61)
Date: Wed, 25 Jun 2008 08:36:02 -0700
From: ESCO <escostudyclub@yahoo.com>
Subject: Re: Postings to the esco
Dear Dr. Thomas,
All postings will come through a central server call Listserv. Some posting
s might be blocked or filtered by the server automatically because the serv
er regards them as spam mails. The editors of the ESCOA0usually approve al
l the postings forwarded by the central server unless the postings are filt
ered by the server without notice.
If anyone finds that his or her postings have not been posted, please conta
ct the editors via email (esco@listserv.uic.edu) and forward the message ag
ain.Feel free to let us know if you have more questions.Regards,
Huibi
--- On Tue, 6/24/08, drt@powaybraces.com <drt@powaybraces.com> wrote:
From: drt@powaybraces.com <drt@powaybraces.com>
Subject: Postings to the esco
To: escostudyclub@YAHOO.COM
Date: Tuesday, June 24, 2008, 10:45 AM
It appears that some reply's to the online study club get posted and
some do not. Who is making the decisions about what gets posted and
what does not for the esco study club?
bill thomas
| Dear Dr. Thomas, All postings will come through a central server call Listserv. Some postings might be blocked or filtered by the server automatically because the server regards them as spam mails. The editors of the ESCO usually approve all the postings forwarded by the central server unless the postings are filtered by the server without notice.If anyone finds that his or her postings have not been posted, please contact the editors via email (esco@listserv.uic.edu) and forward the message again.Feel free to let us know if you have more questions.
|
Date: Mon, 23 Jun 2008 22:45:26 -0400
From: charles ruff <orthodmd@MAC.COM>
Subject: Andrews ArticulatorSome years ago, I took the Will and Larry Andrews in
office course.
Larry talked about a plastic articulator he had developed that essentially
captured CR but did little else.
Is anyone using that and how do you like it?Thanks Charlie Ruff
Date: Mon, 23 Jun 2008 21:16:48 -0400
From: Barry Raphael <drbarry@ALIGNMINE.COM>
Subject: The Matasa Study
RE: www.OrthodonticMaterials.com
If I read this right, the best way to improve bond strength is to cook or
microwave our patients. Thanks.a lot.
Barry
From: The Electronic Study Club for Orthodontics
[mailto:ESCO@LISTSERV.UIC.EDU] On Behalf Of ESCO automatic digest system
Sent: Monday, June 23, 2008 12:25 PM
To: ESCO@LISTSERV.UIC.EDU
Subject: ESCO Digest - 19 Jun 2008 to 23 Jun 2008 - Special issue (#2008-61)
href"www.OrthodonticMaterials.com">www.OrthodonticMaterials.com <o:p></o:p></span>
Date: Mon, 23 Jun 2008 13:53:17 EDT
From: Diane Johnson <DHMJDDS@AOL.COM>
Subject: Re: ESCO Digest - 19 Jun 2008 to 23 Jun 2008 - Special issue (#2008-61)
In a message dated 6/23/2008 12:26:30 P.M. Eastern Daylight Time,
LISTSERV@LISTSERV.UIC.EDU writes:
Ted Rothstein, DDS, PhD
Honorary member American Association of Orthodontists
Specialist in Cosmetic Orthodontics
Specialist in OJW
Dr. Rothstein, what is an honorary
member of the AAO? I wasn't aware there
was such a thing for an American orthodontist. Why aren't you a regular
member? And, I know there is no such thing as a specialist in either Cosmetic
Orthodontics, or in OJW. I don't get it.
Diane Johnson
From: drt@powaybraces.com <drt@powaybraces.com>
Subject: Postings to the esco
To: escostudyclub@YAHOO.COM
Date: Tuesday, June 24, 2008, 10:45 AM
It appears that some reply's to the online study club get posted and some do not. Who is making the decisions about what gets posted and what does not for the esco study club? bill thomasEnd of ESCO Digest - 23 Jun 2008 to 25 Jun 2008 (#2008-62)
SUBJECT: HERE IS THE RESPONSE OF ONE ESCO MEMBER WHO SENT HIS RESPONSE DIRECTLY TO ME
Thank you for your abhorrent email. I pity you old curmudgeon.
Ted Rothstein, DDS, PhD
Life active member American
Association of Orthodontists
Specialist in Cosmetic Orthodontics
Specialist in OJW
Founder DPOJW
www.drted.com/DPOJW.html
35 Remsen St.
Brooklyn, NY 11201
(718) 852-1551
www.drted.com
drted35@aol.com
Ted Rothstein, DDS, PhD
Life active
member American Association of Orthodontists
Specialist in Cosmetic Orthodontics
Specialist in OJW
Founder DPOJW
www.drted.com/DPOJW.html
35 Remsen St.
Brooklyn, NY 11201
(718) 852-1551
www.drted.com
drted35@aol.com
In a message dated 6/27/2008 12:12:09 P.M. Eastern Daylight Time, templedentist@gmail.com writes:
Dr. Ted,
I originally wrote this to be emailed to everyone on the ESCO email list, but thought I'd send it to you directly since some people might interpret this as bashing. I am in fact not trying to bash anyone, but rather to bring to your attention how myself, and possibly others feel about the issues below.
Calling yourself a Specialist in Cosmetic Orthodontics is misleading since there is no such thing, no matter how you justify it. Every orthodontist in the U.S. can find a way to justify calling themselves a Specialist in Cosmetic Orthodontics, but we don't because it isn't a specialty and only serves to "one-up" other orthodontists. It is similar to claiming that you are somehow better than other orthodontists, which I interpret the following sentences from your website to be:
"My experience and reputation are unsurpassed by any other orthodontist in Brooklyn"
"ABOVE ALL, I have treated more than 7000 patients in the 30 years that I am Brooklyn Heights' leading orthodontist."
"Nobody does it better…"
All of the aforementioned is in violation of the Principles of Ethics and Code of Professional Conduct, as far as I understand them to be. (See below)
5.F.2. Examples of "False Or Misleading." -"contain a material, objective representation, whether express or implied, that the advertised services are superior in quality to those of other dentists," taken from the Principles of Ethics and Code of Professional Conduct.
5.H. Announcement of Specialization And Limitation Of Practice. This section and Section 5-I are designed to help the public make an informed selection between the practitioner who has completed an accredited program beyond the dental degree and a practitioner who has not completed such a program. The special areas of dental practice approved by the American Dental Association and the designation for ethical specialty announcement and limitation of practice are: dental public health, endodontics, oral and maxillofacial pathology, oral and maxillofacial radiology, oral and maxillofacial surgery, orthodontics and dentofacial orthopedics, pediatric dentistry, periodontics and prosthodontics.
5.H.2. Specialist Announcement of Credentials in Non-Specialty Interest Areas. A dentist who is qualified to announce specialization under this section may not announce to the public that he or she is certified or a diplomate or otherwise similarly credentialed in an area of dentistry not recognized as a specialty area by the American Dental Association unless:
- The organization granting the credential grants certification or diplomate status based on the following: a) the dentist's successful completion of a formal, full-time advanced education program (graduate or postgraduate level) of at least 12 months' duration; and b) the dentist's training and experience; and c) successful completion of an oral and written examination based on psychometric principles; and
- The announcement includes the following language: [Name of announced area of dental practice] is not recognized as a specialty area by the American Dental Association.
And by the way, how are you a member of the AAO without being a member of the ADA? Membership in the ADA is required to be an AAO member. I ask this since on your website it states that you voluntarily resigned from the ADA in 1995, but remained a member of the AAO and then in 2007 your status with the AAO changed to Honorary Member.
It concerns me that many dental professionals don't follow the rules set forth by the AAO and the ADA, whether intentional or not, even though we all agreed to. (See membership application to the AAO)
I end this by saying that I don't doubt that you are an excellent orthodontist and I can tell you work very hard to make his patients satisfied with their experience and outcome of their treatment.
SUBJECT: DR. ROTHSTEIN RESPONDS TO DOCTOR WHO ASK WHAT HONORARY MEMBER OF THE AAO MEANS. (ESCO Digest - 23 Jun 2008 to 25 Jun 2008 (#2008-62) (THE DOCTOR WAS CORRECT: I MADE A MISTAKE. I AM A LIFE ACTIVE MEMBER NOT AN HONORARY MEMBER)
Ted Rothstein, DDS, PhD
Honorary member American Association of Orthodontists
Specialist in Cosmetic Orthodontics
Specialist in OJW
Dr. Rothstein, what is an honorary member of the AAO? I wasn't aware there
was such a thing for an American orthodontist. Why aren't you a regular
member? And, I know there is no such thing as a specialist in either Cosmetic
Orthodontics, or in OJW. I don't get it.
Diane Johnson
There are 3 messages totalling 34738 lines in this issue.
Topics in this special issue:
1. ESCO Digest - 16 Jun 2008 to 17 Jun 2008 (#2008-58)
2. Variable Torque & The Damon System
3. Dr.Ted Rothstein film on jaw wiring for weight control June 25 11:30am twc
34/67
Date: Fri, 20 Jun 2008 17:56:04 EDT
From: Diane Johnson <DHMJDDS@AOL.COM>
Subject: Re: ESCO Digest - 16 Jun 2008 to 17 Jun 2008 (#2008-58)
To All:
After reading the thread with regards to starting a grid on the (+) and (-)
of various brackets, I was contacted several times by a Dr. Matasa, who has
asked me to supply you a link to this most recently completed an independent
study on the bond strengths of 32 different brackets. It is well done. I do
not know him, I do not use this company, nor do I have any affiliation with
the company. www.OrthodonticMaterials.com Mark
Date: Sun, 22 Jun 2008 06:10:08 EDT
From: Drted35@AOL.COM
Subject: Dr.Ted Rothstein film on jaw wiring for weight control June 25 11:30am twc 34/67
Ted Rothstein, DDS, PhD
Orthodontist for Adults and Children
35 Remsen St., Brooklyn, NY 11201
ou are invited to view the airing of a BCAT 56 minute Special, Wednesday
June 25, 11:30 AM on TWC Ch 34/67; Excerpts from the film will be presented
to colleagues at the American Association of Orthodontists meeting in Boston,
May 2009.
The purpose of the film is to familiarize fellow professionals with Orthodontic Jaw Wiring a device and method to help carefully selected overwight perrsons regain control of their compulsive overeating.
Obesity is legion and epidemic and recognized as a precursor to a host of serious illnesses. OJW for obesity is a treatment modality for a serious"social, psychological and physiological problem that can help carefully selected patients to regain control of their weight thereby reducing or preventing the
potentially grave consequences associated with obesity. I am exploring the "orthodontic" approach to help alleviate this epidemic in those cases where
itmay be applicable. I think dental professionals can deliver this service with compassion and intelligence. My experience to date is that it is safe, and reasonably effective when performed with the proper protocols that I have developed.
Ted Rothstein, DDS, PhD
Honorary member American Association of Orthodontists
Specialist in Cosmetic Orthodontics
Specialist in OJW
Founder DPOJW _www.drted.com/DPOJW.html_ (http://www.drted.com/DPOJW.html)
35 Remsen St.
Brooklyn, NY 11201
(718) 852-1551
_www.drted.com_ (http://www.drted.com/)
_drted35@aol.com_ (mailto:drted35@aol.com)
PIHOTOGRAPH 2ND PHOTOGRAPH
IN BRIEF: Jaws are wired APART about this much |--| Wires are to be released every 5 weeks for 5 days to permit jaw joints to move fully.
What is Orthodontic Jaw Wiring? http://www.drted.com/OJW%20DPOJW%20Course.htm)
Ten reasons to provide this service to your patients: (http://www.drted.com/OJW%20Ten%20reasons%20to%20provide%20OJW.htm)
(http://www.drted.com/OJW%20Ten%20reasons%20to%20provide%20OJW.htm)